LAR
SF
NYG
@DEN
@PHI
BUF
ARI
@LV
LAC
@WAS
GB
KC
DAL
@SEA
@TBMatthew Stafford (QB, LAR) — 2026 evaluation
Verdict — FADE (medium confidence)
Stafford is the reigning MVP and 2025's QB3 in this scoring (358.4 pts, 21.08 PPG — computed from nflverse weekly.csv, pulled 2026-07-07), being drafted as QB13 at pick 100.9 — the first pick past the QB7–12 dead zone. The market has already regressed him ~10 spots, which is why this is a medium-confidence FADE and not an AVOID. Why the market is wrong: at 100.9 it is still paying an MVP-glow premium of 2–3 rounds over same-archetype pocket passers (Mayfield 120.3 — 2025's QB12 with a rushing sprinkle; Love 130.0) and over younger QBs with actual rushing floors (Caleb Williams 106.3, Nix 115.6), while every regression vector on Stafford points one direction: a 7.7% TD rate that has fallen for all 23 prior qualifying QBs (avg −2.2 pts — FantasyLife, 2026), an 8-INT ledger sitting far below his 19 turnover-worthy plays (PFF 2025 — luck lands in 2026), and an age-38 season with a spinal-injury thread and zero rushing insurance (1 rush yard, 0 rush TD in 2025). His median outcome (~272 pts, ~QB13) merely refunds the pick; his 20th-percentile outcome is a 2024 replay (he was QB19, 13.9 PPG in this scoring in 2024 — same team, same play-caller) or a lost season, and no rushing floor absorbs any of it. Per qb.md §11, a late-career pocket QB requires an elite environment and a near-free price; he has the environment, not the price. Fine player, wrong price — draft only at a round-plus discount (pick ~113+, QB15-ish cost).
Bull case
- The environment is the NFL's best and returns wholesale: 10th-year McVay with top-3 PROE, elite PA rate, a top-8 OL in both phases, Nacua + Adams, ~0 vacated targets, and an 11.5 win total — the 2025 efficiency was environment-supported, not thin luck, and the same machine reboots in 2026.
- The QB-owned skills showed zero age decay at 37: +0.243 EPA/dropback, league-best 7.7% big-time-throw rate, pressure-to-sack cut to 12.1%, 3.7% sack rate (all 2025 — nflverse/PFF). The arm and pocket craft are demonstrably intact; nothing in the film-adjacent metrics says the cliff has arrived.
- Even the regressed median refunds the pick: ~4,200 yds / 29 TD lands ~QB13 total and ~QB8–10 by PPG at QB13 cost — and if the Adams red-zone connection keeps the TD rate anywhere near 6%, he smashes (p80 ≈ QB4–6). The market already did most of the regression work for you.
Bear case
- Zero rushing insurance, worst at the position: 29 carries for 1 yard and 0 TDs in the MVP year (nflverse 2025). Every point must arrive by air — even in 2025 he posted 6 of 17 weeks at ≤15.8 pts in this scoring. In 4pt/1QB the profile is a streaming archetype, not a round-9 pick.
- Three regression vectors stacked: 7.7% TD rate (all 23 prior ≥7% qualifiers fell, avg −2.2 pts; inside-10 pass TD rate 46.6% vs 25.6% in 2024 — FantasyLife 2026); 8 INTs vs 19 turnover-worthy plays two years running (PFF — the luck lands); and the in-building counterfactual is 2024: QB19, 13.9 PPG, same coach, same scheme, merely neutral PROE.
- Age 38 with a spine thread and a #13-overall successor: 2022 season ended by spinal cord contusion; 2025 camp back injury now managed via a reduced 2026 throwing program (SI, June 2026). The downside tail is not a slow season — it is a lost one, with the Rams holding a ready-made reason to turn the page during the fantasy playoffs.
Projection & comps
Bottom-up, league scoring (4pt pass TD, −1 INT, 0.1 rush yd, −2 fum lost). Median assumes 16 games (age 38, back history — see games risk):
| Component | Floor (p20, 13 gm) | Median (p50, 16 gm) | Ceiling (p80, 17 gm) | Method |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pass attempts | 449 (34.5/gm) | 560 (35.0/gm) | 604 (35.5/gm) | Team profile: 64.5 plays/gm × ~58% dropback − sacks ≈ 35 att/gm; Stafford 2025 = 35.1 att/gm, 2024 = 32.3 (nflverse) |
| Pass yards (YPA) | 3,188 (7.1) | 4,228 (7.55) | 4,772 (7.9) | 2025 YPA 7.88 / 2024 7.28 (nflverse); environment fully retained (profile: ~0 vacated targets, 4/5 OL back) → blend with age haircut |
| Pass TD | 20 (4.4%) | 29 (5.2%) | 36 (6.0%) | Provider passing xTD UNVERIFIED; anchored to regressed TD rate — 2025 actual 7.7% vs career 4.8% (FantasyLife, 2026); all 23 prior ≥7% seasons fell, avg −2.2 pts; inside-10 pass TD rate 46.6% (vs 25.6% in 2024) also regresses; Adams RZ role + PROE +3–6% keeps him above career rate |
| INT | 10 | 11 | 12 | From TWP, not actuals: 19 TWP / 627 dropbacks = 3.3% (PFF 2025); 3.7% (2024) → ~2.0% INT rate. Actual 1.3% two straight years = luck |
| Rushing | 5 yds, 0 TD | ~10 yds, 0–1 TD | ~15 yds, 1 TD | 29 car / 1 yd / 0 TD 2025; 30 / 41 / 0 2024 (nflverse, incl. kneels) — sneak/kneel only, no designed role |
| Fumbles lost | 4 | 3 | 3 | 3 lost 2025 (1 rush + ~2 sack — nflverse reconciliation of 350.38 fp) |
| Points | ≈193 | ≈272 | ≈320 |
Median 272 ≈ QB13 by total / ~QB8–10 by PPG (17.0) on 2025's league-scoring table; floor ≈ QB19–22 (below replacement — droppable); ceiling ≈ QB4–6 (18.8 PPG). Note 2025's actual 358 sits beyond the p80 — that is the point.
Games risk: medium. Games played 2022→2025: 9 (concussion + season-ending spinal cord contusion), 15 (thumb UCL), 16, 17 (Draft Sharks injury history + nflverse, fetched 2026-07-07). Played all 33 regular-season games the last two years, but the 2025 training-camp back injury produced a managed program that carried into 2026: light/modified throwing at May–June OTAs and minicamp (SI/Turf Show Times, fetched 2026-07-07). Age 38 + spine thread caps this at medium even with the recent durability.
Comps (late-career / post-TD-spike pocket QBs; historical, pre-2026 knowledge unless noted):
- Matt Ryan 2017 — the canonical post-MVP comp: 7.1% TD rate in 2016 → 4.8% and ~QB15 the next year in the same offense-minus-OC
- Tom Brady 2022 (age 45, after 43-TD 2021): volume held (~4,700 yds), TDs crashed to 25 — yardage-only pocket seasons land QB12–15 in 4pt
- Aaron Rodgers 2022 (age 39, post-back-to-back MVP): 26 TD, ~QB17 — MVP-glow fade exemplar
- Drew Brees 2018–19 (age 39–40, elite environment): efficiency held but 5 missed games in 2019 — elite per-game, missed-time total
- Matthew Stafford 2024 (himself): 222.6 pts, 13.91 PPG, QB19 in this scoring (computed from repo weekly.csv, 2026-07-07) — the live in-building floor case
Usage profile (qb.md §2 opportunity core + §5 efficiency)
| Metric | 2024 | 2025 | Band | Read |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rush attempts / gm | 1.88 | 1.71 | Concern (<2.5) | nflverse; nearly all kneels/sneaks |
| Designed rush rate | ~0% real | ~0% real | Concern | 29 carries → 1 net yard, 3 first downs (nflverse 2025); no designed package exists |
| Scramble rate | UNVERIFIED (split unavailable) | UNVERIFIED | Concern by inference | 1 net rush yd on the season makes material scrambling arithmetically impossible |
| Rush yds / gm | 2.6 | 0.1 | Concern (<10) | The rushing floor is zero — worst at the position |
| RZ rush share / inside-5 carries | UNVERIFIED (FTN charting lacks player join) | UNVERIFIED | Concern by inference | 0 rush TD in each of last two seasons (nflverse) |
| Rushing xTD | ~0 | ~0–0.5 | Concern (<1.5) | Sneak-only TD access |
| Dropbacks / gm | 34.1 | 36.5 | Good (33–38) | att + sacks, nflverse weekly |
| Pass attempts / gm | 32.3 | 35.1 | Elite/Good line | The volume is real and elite-adjacent |
| Team PROE | −3.0% (t-19th) | +3.0 to +6.0% (top-3) | Elite | nfelo/FantasyLife via team profile (fetched 2026-07-07) — deliberate 2025 philosophical shift, same caller returns |
| xFP | UNVERIFIED (no provider table) | UNVERIFIED — usage read: QB1/2 fringe | — | Top-8 pass volume × elite environment, minus all rushing |
| EPA / dropback | +0.060 | +0.243 | Elite (2025) | Computed: nflverse weekly passing_epa ÷ (att+sacks), pulled 2026-07-07. Two-season rule: 2025 is a single-season efficiency spike over 2024 |
| CPOE | −0.62 | +1.48 | Good (2025) | NGS season rows, nflverse. Same caveat — the 2024 number is the other recent sample |
| Pressure-to-sack | 17.5% | 12.1% | Elite | PFF (fetched 2026-07-07); 3.7% sack rate 2025 — QB-owned, sticky, genuinely intact |
| TWP rate | 3.7% | 3.3% (19 TWP/627 db) | Mid | PFF (fetched 2026-07-07). Red flag: 1.3% actual INT rate two straight years — INTs regress up |
| Deep ball / aggressiveness | aDOT 7.71 | aDOT 9.10, aggr. 18.6%, BTT 7.7% (league best) | Elite band | NGS (nflverse) + PFF — the passing ceiling is real when he plays |
| Play-action rate (team) | UNVERIFIED | 32.7% | Elite | FTN via team profile — play-caller-owned, returns with McVay |
Archetype (qb.md §10): pocket volume passer — "worth starter price only in 6pt-TD or superflex formats" — overlaid with the §11 late-career pocket QB pattern ("the cliff is sudden"). Red flags hit (§12): INTs well below TWP; price partially paying a TD-rate spike; age-38 pocket profile; R1 successor drafted (one of three benching-risk legs — survivable alone). Green flags hit: none on the checklist.
Context (from data/team-profiles/LAR.md, built 2026-07-07)
- Play-caller: Sean McVay, 10th season, confirmed retaining play-calling after the staff reshuffle (LaFleur → ARI; Scheelhaase OC, Kingsbury asst. HC). 2025 signatures return: PROE +3–6% (top-3), 32.7% PA, 50.6% motion, 30.2% 13-personnel. Continuity, not reinvention.
- Job security: "This is Matthew's team" (McVay at the draft, ESPN, Apr 2026); 1-yr/$55M extension, $40M fully guaranteed (NFL.com, Mar 2026). Ty Simpson (R1 #13) projects QB3 early, no starts expected barring injury (Yardbarker/NBC Sports, fetched 2026-07-07). Benching risk none; injury-pivot risk real — Stafford is under contract exactly one more year and the successor is in the building.
- O-line: 7th PBWR / 4th RBWR, 4 of 5 starters back; RT McClendon already logged ~900 quality 2025 snaps post-Havenstein. No pressure red flag.
- Weapons: Nacua (166 tgt, 28.6% TS) + Adams (114 tgt, 14 rec TD — contract year) + four-deep TE room; vacated targets ~15 (effectively zero). Best-retained supporting cast in football.
- Script: Vegas win total 11.5 (DK/FD, early July 2026) — positive-script lean trims ~1 pt off pass rate; team projects ~35 pass att/gm.
- 2026 health status: publicly committed to his 18th season (therams.com); no injury designation (Sleeper, 2026-07-07); modified/light throwing program at OTAs/minicamp May–June 2026 following the 2025 camp back injury (SI/Turf Show Times, fetched 2026-07-07).
Tripwires (void this eval; re-run on trigger)
- Back flare-up or missed practice time in training camp (opens late July 2026) → FADE hardens to AVOID at any starter price; fires the team-profile contingency line (Simpson/Bennett).
- ADP drifts past ~113 (round 10+, QB15-ish cost) → the price objection dissolves; flips toward HOLD/TARGET.
- McVay delegates play-calling (to Kingsbury/Scheelhaase) or any McVay health/step-back news → PROE and PA assumptions void; re-derive passing environment.
- Adams traded, released, or injured (contract year; a failed trade attempt was already reported at league meetings — ESPN, Mar 2026) → red-zone TD environment re-derives downward.
- League settings confirmed as 6pt pass TD or superflex → verdict re-runs under qb.md §9; FADE likely flips.
Sources
data/stats/2025/&data/stats/2024/(nflverse via nflreadpy, pulled 2026-07-07): passing.csv, rushing.csv, weekly.csv (EPA, per-game points, QB ranking tables computed 2026-07-07), ngs_passing.csv (CPOE, aDOT, TTT, aggressiveness), pbp_summary.csv (team plays/pass rate)data/team-profiles/LAR.md(built 2026-07-07): play-caller, PROE, OL ranks, depth chart, vacated targets, win total, contingency linedata/adp/adp_ffc_2026-07-07.csv: ADP 100.9, QB13 (FFC PPR mocks, 2026-07-07)data/raw/sleeper/players_2026-07-07.json: age 38 (DOB 1988-02-07), 17 yrs exp, depth chart #1, no injury status- PFF (fetched 2026-07-07): 2025 TWP 3.3% (19/627), pressure-to-sack 12.1% (from 17.5%), BTT 7.7% league-best, passing grade 91.7 (#1); 2026 QB Annual takeaways
- FantasyLife "Matthew Stafford Fantasy Football Outlook For 2026" (fetched 2026-07-07): TD-rate 7.7% vs career 4.8%; all-23-QBs ≥7% regression stat (avg −2.2); inside-10 pass TD rate 46.6% vs 25.6%; market framing ("very live as a quality late-round QB")
- therams.com (fetched 2026-07-07): Stafford publicly commits to 18th season; 2026 coaching staff
- ESPN league-meetings takeaways, Mar 2026 (fetched 2026-07-07): backup plan, failed Adams trade note
- FOX Sports / Yardbarker / NBC Sports (fetched 2026-07-07): Simpson #13 pick, "this is Matthew's team" (McVay), QB3-through-October projection, one-year contract runway
- SI / Turf Show Times / Draft Sharks (fetched 2026-07-07): 2025 camp back-injury timeline, 2026 modified OTA throwing program, injury history (2022: 9 gm spinal contusion; 2023: 15 gm thumb UCL)
- Comp seasons (Ryan 2017, Brady 2022, Rodgers 2022, Brees 2018–19): historical, pre-2026 assistant knowledge — directionally reliable, exact ranks UNVERIFIED