CHI
@CAR
MIN
PHI
NYJ
@GB
@ATL
NE
@SEA
TB
NO
@DET
JAX
@MIA
@BUFD'Andre Swift (RB, CHI) — 2026
Verdict
HOLD (medium confidence) at ADP 48.3 (FFC PPR, 2026-07-07 — RB21, early 4th round in 12-team). The market sees an age-27 contract-year back coming off a career year with an ascending 7th-round 1B (Monangai) behind him, and prices him ~5 spots below his 2025 PPG finish (#16). That discount is approximately correct. The sticky, PPR-relevant half of his role — 53% of third downs, 61% of two-minute snaps, 50% of inside-5 carries, flat snap share in every score state on a 9.5-win, 4th-in-plays offense — is more secure than the "Monangai overtakes" narrative implies (Monangai's pass protection is a coach-confirmed gate). But the efficiency that made 2025 a career year (+0.58 RYOE/att after four straight negative seasons) is a one-year change the evidence hierarchy says not to believe, and the committee caps the ceiling at pick-48 expectations rather than exceeding them. Profile and price agree; no "market is wrong" thesis clears the bar. Take him if he slips past ~60; don't reach.
Bull case
- The PPR-relevant half of the role is banked and gated: 53% of third downs, 61% of two-minute snaps, 3.0 targets/g for six straight years — and the only challenger's pass protection is publicly criticized by his own position coach (Marquee, June 2026). Ben Johnson moved these downs *to* Swift in year 1 (from Roschon's 52% in 2024); they are the last thing a play-caller takes away.
- Script-proof volume on one of the best RB environments in football: flat 52–56% snap share in every score state, 9.5-win total, 4th in plays/game, #5 run-block win rate, 50% of inside-5 carries in a 441-point offense. The floor at pick 48 is as solid as any RB in the round.
- The takeover the market fears never got funded: an offseason of cut/trade chatter ended with no RB drafted, no veteran signed, and Swift kept at an $8.8M cap hit — while he posted his first positive-RYOE season (+0.58/att), a 48% success rate, and PFF's most-improved-RB honor behind a line that returns its elite interior.
Bear case
- You're buying the career year at age 27: +0.58 RYOE/att and 4.87 YPC came after four straight seasons of negative RYOE (−0.69 in 2024) — a one-year efficiency change the framework explicitly says not to believe. Regress him to ~4.4 YPC and the median lands ~205, exactly what pick 48 already pays for, with zero margin of safety.
- The 1B is coming, and the leading indicator already fired: Monangai took 41% of rookie-year snaps, out-carried Swift 12–14 inside the 5 down the stretch of a near-even goal-line split, and his third-down share rose to 45% over weeks 13–18 — the §11 "routes/third-downs rising late" signal that precedes a role jump. The org calls him the successor and owes Swift nothing after 2026; one Swift slump or trade-deadline pivot flips this backfield.
- Good-band everything, elite-band nothing: 57.9% snaps, 57.3% opportunity share, 4.5 HVT/g, 3.0 targets/g — no single metric clears an elite threshold, so the 80th-percentile outcome (~260) is merely what round-2 RBs deliver at median. Round 4 is where you draft ceilings; Swift is a floor pick in a ceiling slot.
Projection & comps
Bottom-up from the team profile's volume model (~65 plays/g, ~28 rush att/g of which ~23 are RB carries → ~391 RB carries; ~570 team pass att, 14.9% RB target share ≈ ~85 RB targets; data/team-profiles/CHI.md, 2026-07-07):
| Scenario | Games | Carries | Rush yds | Targets | Rec | Rec yds | TDs | PPR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Floor (20th) — Monangai's split flips to lead by midseason and/or Swift misses 2–3 games; Swift keeps passing downs only | 14 | ~155 @ 4.0 | 620 | 35 | 25 | 215 | 4 | ~130 |
| Median (50th) — 2025 split roughly holds (≈55/45 of RB carries), efficiency regresses from 4.87 to ~4.4, TDs to xTD | 16 | ~208 @ 4.4 | 915 | 51 | 36 | 320 | 8 | ~205 |
| Ceiling (80th) — Monangai stalls or misses time; Swift back toward his 2024 58% carry share with 2025 efficiency mostly holding | 16–17 | ~235 @ 4.6 | 1,080 | 58 | 42 | 375 | 11 | ~260 |
- TDs anchored to xTD, not 2025's 10 (9 rush + 1 rec): his 2025 red-zone usage — 24 inside-10 carries (44.4% team share), 14 inside-5 (50.0%) in a 441-point offense — supports roughly 7.5–8.5 xTD (internal estimate from pbp usage; provider xTD UNVERIFIED). 2025 was near expectation, not TD luck, but Monangai took 12 inside-5 carries of his own, so median assumes the split persists (7 rush + 1 rec).
- Games-played risk: medium — 33 of 34 regular-season games the last two years, but this is his age-27 season (DOB 1999-01-14, Sleeper 2026-07-07) and RB baseline risk is elevated. Career REG touches 1,340 (1,069 carries + 271 receptions over 89 games, computed from nflverse 2020–2025, pulled 2026-07-07) — well below the 1,800 cliff; the age trigger fires, the mileage trigger does not, and the receiving profile is the kind that ages best (rb.md §8).
- Comps: Aaron Jones 2024 MIN (~229 PPR — veteran lead under committee pressure on a good offense); Alvin Kamara 2022 NO (~223 — age-27 receiving-tilted vet, modest TDs); David Montgomery 2023 DET (~220 — the committee half of a Ben Johnson backfield); James Conner 2022 ARI (~183 — the age-27 games-missed version); Swift's own 2024 (214.5 on a bad offense) as the floor-side sanity check. Cluster 185–230 brackets the median.
- External projections: none in
data/projections/(directory absent) — no cross-check available.
Usage profile (rb.md §2 table)
All cached numbers: nflverse via nflreadpy (pulled 2026-07-07), REG only. Pbp-derived rows computed 2026-07-07 by joining participation.csv to nflverse play-by-play.
| Metric | 2024 (17 g) | 2025 (16 g) | Band (2025) | Read |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Snap share (avg, snap_counts.csv) | 66.8% | 57.9% | Good (50–65) | Ceded ~9 pts to rookie Monangai (40.9%); never below 45% in any game |
| Opportunity share (RB carries+targets) | 78.4% | 57.3% | Good (55–70) | 2×2: snap and opp share aligned — real 1A, not a grinder |
| Weighted opps/g (car + 2.5×tgt) | 22.5 | 21.4 | Good (18–25) | Volume held despite the committee because team volume is 4th in NFL |
| High-value touches/g (tgt + inside-10 car) | 4.1 | 4.5 | Good (4–6) | The scoring engine is real but not bellcow-grade |
| Inside-10 carries (team share) | 18 (54.5%) | 24 (44.4%) | Good | Monangai took 21 (38.9%) — genuinely split |
| Inside-5 carry share | 10 (41.7%) | 14 (50.0%) | Good (40–60) | Swift-tilted, not Swift-owned (Monangai 12, 42.9%) |
| Third-down snap share | 29.3% (Roschon Johnson had 52.4%) | 53.1% (Monangai 38.6%) | Good (40–70) | Ben Johnson moved the passing downs TO Swift in year 1 — role gained, not inherited |
| Two-minute snap share | 43.9% | 60.7% (Monangai 34.0%) | Good | Trust-signal downs are Swift's |
| Routes/g · route participation | 24.8/g · 61.2% on-field-dropback proxy | 21.7/g · 53.9% proxy | Good | True routes UNVERIFIED (no routes table); proxy includes pass-block snaps |
| TPRR | 0.123 proxy | 0.138 proxy | Concern-to-mid | Target volume is participation-driven, not earning-rate-driven; true TPRR UNVERIFIED |
| Targets/g | 3.1 | 3.0 | Good (3–5) | Six straight seasons ≥ 3.0/g — the stable core of his value |
| xFP | UNVERIFIED (provider) | UNVERIFIED (provider) | — | Internal usage estimate ≈ 13.4 xPPG vs 14.3 actual — mild efficiency overperformance, not usage luck |
| Actual PPG (PPR) | 12.6 | 14.3 (#16 per PlayerProfiler, retrieved 2026-07-07) | RB2 range | — |
Game-script read (rb.md §4, explicit): Does he leave the field when trailing? No. 2025 snap share by score state: 56.0% trailing by 7+, 53.2% within one score, 52.3% leading by 7+ — flat everywhere (pbp join, 2026-07-07). On a 9.5-win-total team (BetMGM/DK, 2026-07-07) that led often, he got clock-killing carries; when trailing he stayed on for routes. This is the script-proof shape whose projection barely moves with team quality — the floor scenario is committee-driven, not script-driven.
Late-season split (wks 13–18, 2025): Swift 56.3% snaps / 57.2% of dropbacks / 52.3% of third downs — stable to slightly up. Monangai 43.0% / 41.5% / 45.3% — his third-down presence rose from a 38.6% season-long base. Swift's role held; Monangai's grew at the margins. Per rb.md §11, a rising late-season third-down trend is the leading indicator to watch — it belongs to the *backup* here, which is the one genuinely worrying line in this table.
Efficiency (§5) — separating back from line
| Metric | 2024 | 2025 | Band |
|---|---|---|---|
| NGS RYOE/att (ngs_rushing.csv) | −0.69 | +0.58 | Concern → good (near-elite) |
| Rush success rate (pbp) | 34.0% | 48.0% | Concern → good |
| EPA/rush (pbp) | −0.154 | +0.069 | — |
| 15+ yd run rate (pbp) | 3.6% | 5.4% | Good |
| YPC | 3.79 | 4.87 | (least predictive; noted only) |
| YAC/att | UNVERIFIED | ~3.0 (754 yds after contact; PFF via web summaries, retrieved 2026-07-07 — likely incl. playoffs) | Mid (3.0–3.5) |
| MTF/touch | UNVERIFIED | 45 forced ≈ 0.16–0.18/touch (PFF via web summaries, retrieved 2026-07-07; approximate) | Good band, low end |
| 8+ box rate (NGS) | 22.5% | 20.6% | Neutral |
| PFF grade | 61.3 | 82.7, 9th among qualifiers (SI, 2026-01-15; a later summary lists 81.0/11th of 55) — PFF's "most-improved RB" | — |
Read honestly: the 2024→2025 swing tracks the line as much as the back — CHI's run-blocking went to RBWR 74%, 5th in NFL (ESPN, 2026-01-06) and rookie Monangai posted +0.29 RYOE/att behind the same line. Swift's +0.58 is his first positive RYOE season of the four in our data window, and the evidence hierarchy (scoring-framework §3) requires two seasons before believing an efficiency change. The median projection therefore prices ~4.4 YPC, not 4.87. His burst indicators (5.4% breakaway, mid-band MTF) show no §11 decline sequence yet — this is not a fading back, just one who shouldn't be paid for a career-year repeat.
Context (team profile, data/team-profiles/CHI.md, built 2026-07-07)
- Play-caller: Ben Johnson, year 2, calls plays (new OC Press Taylor does not). Run-tilted (PROE −3.9%), 4th in plays/g (67.1), 8th in EPA/play, wide-zone base with duo mixed — fits Swift's one-cut profile (profile: "fits one-cut sudden backs (Swift)"). No scheme-mismatch flag.
- Offense quality / script prior: win total 9.5 (BetMGM/DK, 2026-07-07) → positive-script lean; 441 points scored in 2025. Positive scripts feed carries, and Swift holds the trailing-script work too (see §3) — both worlds pay him.
- OL: PBWR #1, RBWR #5 (ESPN, through wk18 2025); interior (Thuney/Jackson) elite and returning; risk concentrated at LT (oft-injured Braxton Jones, top backup Trapilo out 9–12 months) and a Bradbury-for-Dalman downgrade at C. Net: still a top-tier run-blocking environment, with a single point of failure.
- Committee (§7): 2025 split — Swift 223 carries/48 targets vs Monangai 169/30; snaps 57.9% vs 40.9%. Camp reporting (Marquee/247/SI, June 2026, via team profile): Swift RB1, Monangai "the 1B pushing for more," org views Monangai as the eventual successor, and RB coach Bienemy has been publicly critical of Monangai's pass protection — the §9 gate that keeps third down and two-minute with Swift. No RB capital added: no RB in CHI's 2026 draft class (ESPN draft tracker via team profile, fetched 2026-07-07) and no veteran RB signed (ESPN/A-to-Z FA trackers; confirmed via search 2026-07-07); depth is Roschon Johnson/Brittain Brown/Deion Hankins. Monangai's claim is a 2025 R7 pick — production, not capital.
- 2×2 placement: high-ish standalone / moderate contingent — locked 1A whose capable backup absorbs any expansion. "Fine at price, capped upside" is the quadrant's own verdict.
- Contract (§9): final year of 3yr/$24M; $6.39M base, $8.80M cap hit in 2026 (Spotrac, retrieved 2026-07-07). Offseason cut/trade speculation died — he's staying (clutchpoints/beat consensus, June 2026). Contract-year performance narratives are noise per rb.md §9 and are ignored; the structural fact that matters is CHI has zero commitment beyond 2026 and a successor in-house.
- Ambiguous-backfield pricing check (§7 trap): backfield total ≈ 380 PPR (2025 actuals: Swift 228.6 + Monangai 146.7 + scraps). Swift's ADP-implied ~190–210 ≈ his ~55% allocation (~210); Monangai at ADP 103.8 implies ~140–150 vs a ~45% allocation (~170). The market is not over-allocating this backfield — no trap fires.
Tripwires (re-run this eval if any fire)
- Camp/preseason (opens late July): Monangai takes first-team third-down or two-minute reps, or beat reporting says his pass protection has satisfied Bienemy → the sticky-role thesis breaks; flips toward FADE.
- Preseason goal-line package with starters goes to Monangai → shave ~2 TDs off the median; likely FADE at 48.
- Any CHI RB addition with real guarantees, or a Swift trade/release (contract-year, $8.8M cap hit) → void, re-run from the new depth chart.
- ADP movement: falls past ~60 (5th round) → TARGET; rises inside ~40 → FADE.
- Braxton Jones (LT) injury or OL cascade (Trapilo already out 9–12 months) → downgrade the run-blocking environment and efficiency assumptions.
Note: no evaluations/boards/2026/ directory exists yet; when a board is built it should pick this file up.
Sources
data/stats/2025/anddata/stats/2024/— rushing.csv, receiving.csv, snap_counts.csv, ngs_rushing.csv, participation.csv (nflverse via nflreadpy, pulled 2026-07-07; REG only).- nflverse play-by-play 2020–2025 loaded via nflreadpy on 2026-07-07 — inside-10/inside-5 carries and team shares, success rate, EPA/rush, 15+ yd run rate, score-state and third-down/two-minute snap shares (joined to participation.csv), career touch count (1,069 carries + 271 receptions, REG 2020–2025).
data/adp/adp_ffc_2026-07-07.csv— Swift 48.3 (RB21), Monangai 103.8 (FFC PPR mocks, 2026-07-07).data/raw/sleeper/players_2026-07-07.json— age 27 (DOB 1999-01-14), Georgia, 5'8"/204, years_exp 6, depth_chart_order 1, injury_status none (2026-07-07).data/team-profiles/CHI.md(built 2026-07-07) — Ben Johnson tendencies, OL ranks (ESPN PBWR #1/RBWR #5, 2026-01-06), scheme, volume model, win total 9.5 (BetMGM/DK, 2026-07-07), committee reporting (Marquee/247/SI camp notes incl. Bienemy on Monangai's pass-pro, June 2026), 2026 FA/draft arrivals (no RB).- SI.com Bears: "Swift earns PFF honor" — PFF most-improved RB, 82.7 grade/9th, 61.3 in 2024 (2026-01-15); "3 Reasons Monangai Will Overtake Swift" (2026-06-25).
- Footballguys: "How Will Swift and Monangai Split Touches?" — analyst split projections 55/45–65/35, Swift RB2/RB23 market framing, $8.8M cap-casualty discussion (2026, retrieved 2026-07-07).
- Spotrac via search (retrieved 2026-07-07): 3yr/$24M, 2026 base $6.39M, cap hit $8,803,334, final year.
- clutchpoints/Yahoo/beat summaries (June 2026, retrieved 2026-07-07): Swift staying after offseason trade/cut speculation; Bears 2026 RB depth (Roschon Johnson, Brittain Brown, Deion Hankins).
- PFF via web summaries (retrieved 2026-07-07): 2025 — 45 missed tackles forced, 754 yards after contact (~3.0/att), rushing grade 88.2. Treat as approximate (may include playoffs); not independently verified against a PFF export.
- UNVERIFIED and unavailable: provider xFP/xTD, true routes run and TPRR (proxies used, labeled), exact PFF pass-block grade for Swift, external projections (
data/projections/absent).